With a great product like Speaker Workshop to test
the speaker design why is it important to listen to the prototype?
To
1) Verify that the drivers sound the way you want
them to
2) Tweak the crossover for best sound
IMHO driver sound is vastly overrated. You
will see people talk about how good specific materials sound. For
example, I just read an article by someone who desperately wanted
to build two-ways using 5" drivers to get the "immediate
attack" unavailable with larger drivers. Pooh. Drivers sound
the way their frequency response indicates.
With that said, speaker sound is very dependent on
driver selection, port size, and crossover. Changing the crossover
by a tiny percentage can change regions of the frequency response
that are quite audible. The same is true for port changes. Thus,
it is important to listen to the speaker as you design the crossover.
What to listen for
I have found that there are three things I listen
for.
1) Balance - do the bass, midrange, and treble sound
in balance? This is usually a function of the relative drive of
the woofer and tweeter. It is also a function of the porting-induced
bass response. Listen to wide range music for this - rock and roll
or symphony. I use Celtic music with a harp and deep drums.
2) Even response - are all of the notes at the same
intensity when played that way? I tend to use piano music (or keyboards)
for this. They have a wide range and roughly equal intensity in
some pieces (I usually use Dave Brubek). This points out narrow
peaks and valleys in the frequency response.
3) Timbre - do the instruments sound right? This is
like balance but a good indicator of the top end of the speaker
and the crossover region - where the harmonics live. Cymbals, guitar,
harp, and brass instruments are good here (I use brass because my
wife is a professional French Horn player so I make her listen). |